Subscribe to our newsletters
Settlement Agreements and Wrongful Dismissal: Court Upholds Deal
When an employee is dismissed without cause, wrongful dismissal claims often follow. Many of these disputes are resolved through settlement agreements, which bring finality and allow both sides to move forward. But what happens if an employee accepts a settlement, then later tries to walk away?
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice answered this question in Johnstone v. Loblaw, 2025 ONSC 4755. The Court ruled that a settlement agreement between Loblaw Companies Limited and a former employee was binding, even though the employee later argued that a failed Ottawa house purchase justified reopening the deal.
This case highlights several important principles in employment law, especially around the enforceability of settlement agreements and the scope of releases.
Wrongful Dismissal and Settlement Agreements
Scott Johnstone worked for Loblaw for over seven years. After relocating to Ottawa for work, he was terminated without cause.
Settlement negotiations began, covering notice, benefits, relocation entitlements, and legal fees. Mr. Johnstone’s lawyer confirmed acceptance of Loblaw’s offer by email, creating what appeared to be a final deal.
Shortly after, however, Mr. Johnstone’s Ottawa home purchase collapsed. He attempted to renegotiate, asking Loblaw to cover mortgage guarantees and additional housing costs. Loblaw refused and sought to enforce the original settlement.
Enforceability of Settlement Agreements
The Court confirmed that once the essential terms of a settlement are accepted, the agreement is binding. Formal signatures on minutes of settlement are not required for enforceability if the acceptance is clear.
In this case, the email from the employee’s lawyer confirming instructions to accept Loblaw’s offer was enough to create a binding contract. The employee’s later attempt to add new conditions was dismissed as “buyer’s remorse.”
The Importance of Broad Releases
A key issue was whether the employee could pursue damages from his failed home purchase, separate from his termination. The Court held that the release in the settlement agreement barred such claims because relocation and housing costs had been part of the settlement negotiations.
For employers, this highlights the value of drafting broad release language that clearly covers all claims arising from the employment relationship, not just severance.
Summary Judgment in Employment Disputes
Loblaw brought a motion for summary judgment to enforce the settlement. The Court granted it, finding that a full trial was unnecessary.
This decision confirms that Ontario courts are willing to use summary judgment to resolve wrongful dismissal disputes efficiently, saving time and costs for both parties.
Lessons for Employers and Employees
The Johnstone v. Loblaw decision provides several takeaways for both sides of the employment relationship.
For Employers:
- Settlement agreements, once accepted, will be enforced.
- Broad releases can prevent future claims, including those tied to relocation or housing.
- Summary judgment is an effective tool to enforce settlements quickly.
For Employees:
- Accepting a settlement creates a binding agreement, even if circumstances change.
- Attempts to add new conditions after acceptance will not succeed.
- Relocation and housing costs must be addressed clearly during negotiations, not after.
For businesses and employees across Ontario, this case is a reminder that settlement agreements bring certainty but only if they are carefully negotiated and clearly documented.
Conclusion
Johnstone v. Loblaw reinforces the principle that settlement agreements in employment law provide finality. Once the essential terms are agreed to, the deal stands, regardless of later regrets or unrelated financial losses.
For employers, this decision is a strong reminder of the importance of drafting comprehensive settlement agreements and releases that cover all potential claims.
For employees, it underscores the need to consider the full picture before accepting a settlement.
If your workplace is dealing with a wrongful dismissal or settlement issue, obtaining legal advice early can help protect your rights and ensure any agreement is fair, enforceable, and final.
Settlements Don’t Always Stay Settled
Make Sure Your Settlement Agreements Actually Protect You
A signed settlement is not always the end of the story. If terms are unclear or poorly structured, employers can still face disputes, delays, or unexpected legal exposure. Getting it right the first time matters.
Call 1-800-771-7882
Speak With an Employer Defence LawyerThe article in this client update provides general information and should not be relied on as legal advice or opinion. This publication is copyrighted by Achkar Law Professional Corporation and may not be photocopied or reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express permission of Achkar Law Professional Corporation. ©