Subscribe to our newsletters
Five Employment Law Situations Where You Should Have Called a Lawyer Yesterday
There's a pattern we see with employers, and it's almost universal.
An HR manager or business owner runs into a tricky situation: a termination that doesn't feel clean, a workplace complaint they're not sure how to handle, a contract they've been meaning to update for two years. They think about calling a lawyer. Then they think about the hourly rate. Then they decide to handle it themselves, or wait, or quietly hope it resolves on its own.
Sometimes it does. Often it doesn't.
By the time we get the call, a manageable situation has turned into a formal complaint, a wrongful dismissal claim, or a human rights application. The cost, both financially and operationally, is almost always higher than early legal guidance would have been.
This post is about the five situations where employers most commonly delay getting legal advice, and what the stakes look like when they wait too long.
1You're About to Terminate an Employee (And Something Feels Off)
Termination is the highest-risk moment in any employment relationship. It's also the situation where employers most frequently rely on instinct instead of guidance.
"We have cause" is one of the most dangerous phrases in employment law. Cause for termination is an extremely high legal threshold in Ontario, far higher than most employers realize. Poor performance, attendance issues, attitude problems, and even some forms of misconduct often don't meet the legal standard for just cause, even when they feel obvious from a management perspective.
The consequences of getting this wrong? Wrongful dismissal claims. Human rights applications. Significant damages exposure, including aggravated and punitive damages in cases where the termination process itself was handled poorly.
The earlier you involve legal counsel in a termination, especially one that involves performance management documentation, accommodation history, or any sensitivity around the employee's protected characteristics, the more options you have and the lower your risk.
This is exactly the kind of situation the Fractional Employment Lawyer Program is designed for. Practical, timely guidance before the decision is made, not after a claim lands on your desk.
Learn More Call 1-800-771-78822An Employee Has Raised a Complaint, and You're Not Sure What to Do With It
A complaint comes in. Maybe it's about a coworker's behaviour. Maybe it's about a manager. Maybe it's vague, just that someone "doesn't feel comfortable," and you're not sure if it rises to the level of requiring formal action.
Here's what employers often don't realize: the obligation to respond appropriately is triggered by the complaint itself, not by whether you decide the complaint is valid.
Ontario's Occupational Health and Safety Act and the Human Rights Code create real obligations around workplace harassment, discrimination, and the duty to investigate. Employers who fail to respond, or who respond in a way that looks retaliatory or dismissive, face liability that goes well beyond the original complaint.
Early legal guidance helps you determine: Does this require a formal investigation? Who should conduct it? What documentation do you need? What should you say (and not say) to the people involved?
Those questions are much easier to answer before you've taken steps that complicate the picture.
3You're Updating (Or Still Using) Template Employment Contracts
If your employment contracts were downloaded from the internet, handed down from a previous HR manager, or haven't been reviewed since 2019, there's a real chance they contain clauses that won't hold up.
Courts have struck down termination clauses in Ontario employment contracts for technical deficiencies that employers never noticed, sometimes resulting in employees being entitled to far more notice than the contract intended to provide.
This matters because a properly drafted employment contract is one of the most effective risk management tools available to employers. It sets expectations, limits liability, and protects your organization if the relationship ends. A poorly drafted one can do the opposite.
Reviewing and updating your standard employment agreements is a low-drama, high-value task, exactly the kind of ongoing work that fits a fractional legal relationship rather than a one-time engagement.
Want to understand how the Fractional Employment Lawyer Program handles ongoing contract support?
Learn More About the Program Call 1-800-771-78824You're Managing a Performance Issue, and It's Getting Complicated
Performance management sounds administrative. Legally, it's anything but.
When performance issues intersect with accommodation obligations (a mental health condition, a disability, a family status concern), the process becomes significantly more complex. Employers who document and manage performance without considering whether accommodation obligations have been triggered can find themselves facing human rights complaints even when the underlying performance concern was legitimate.
There's also the paper trail problem. The documentation you create during a performance management process will matter enormously if the relationship eventually ends. Records that are inconsistent, incomplete, or that contain language that could be read as discriminatory can undermine an otherwise defensible termination.
Getting advice early in a performance management process, before the paper trail is established, protects your ability to act on legitimate concerns while managing the legal exposure.
5You Haven't Reviewed Your Workplace Policies in a While
Workplace policies (harassment, accommodation, remote work, social media, hours of work) are living documents. Employment law changes. Court decisions shift what's required and what's enforceable. What was compliant three years ago may not be today.
More practically: policies that exist on paper but aren't consistently applied can actually increase your legal exposure, because they establish standards your organization isn't meeting.
A policy review isn't glamorous. But it's the kind of proactive work that prevents the situations described in this entire post from happening in the first place.
The Common Thread
Every situation above has one thing in common: the cost of early guidance is almost always lower than the cost of fixing a problem that was allowed to develop.
The reason employers delay isn't that they don't value legal advice. Our own client research confirms it: employers hold off because of uncertainty around cost, timing, and whether a situation is "serious enough" to warrant a call.
The Achkar Law Fractional Employment Lawyer Program was built specifically to remove those barriers. A monthly subscription gives you predictable, budgeted access to employment legal guidance, so the question is never "is this worth a call?" It always is.
Questions? Speak with our team directly.
1-800-771-7882Achkar Law's Fractional Employment Lawyer Program provides ongoing legal guidance for employers on terminations, employment contracts, workplace policies, accommodations, and human rights matters. The program does not include litigation, workplace investigations, or full document drafting. For questions about whether the program is right for your organization, please call us directly.