Subscribe to our newsletters
Bardal Factors Explained: How BC Courts Decide Reasonable Notice and Severance
When you are dismissed without cause in BC, your employer must provide reasonable notice or pay in lieu. BC's Employment Standards Act sets a minimum. But for most employees, the real question is what common law reasonable notice requires, and that is determined by the Bardal factors. Understanding how courts apply these factors to your specific situation is often the difference between accepting a low-ball offer and recovering what you are actually owed.
They come from Bardal v. Globe and Mail Ltd. (1960), which established that there is no fixed formula for reasonable notice. Instead, courts assess the full circumstances of the employee including their age, length of service, the nature of their role, and the availability of comparable work. The result is frequently significantly higher than the ESA minimum.
Were you terminated without cause and offered only the ESA minimum?
Most severance offers reflect only the statutory floor. Once you sign a release you give up your right to pursue the difference. Get advice before you sign anything. The gap between what you were offered and what you may be owed can be substantial.
Call: 1-800-771-7882 Get Your Severance ReviewedThe four Bardal factors explained
Character of employment
The nature, seniority, and responsibilities of your role. Senior, specialized, or managerial positions typically attract longer notice periods than entry-level roles because the employee's skills are more specific and the market for comparable positions is narrower.
Length of service
The total duration of your employment. Longer service generally results in higher severance. Courts recognize that long-serving employees have made a greater investment in their employer and face greater disruption from sudden dismissal.
Age of the employee
Older employees often receive longer notice periods because they typically face greater difficulty transitioning to new employment. The older you are at the time of dismissal, the more the court recognizes the challenge of finding comparable work quickly.
Availability of similar employment
The state of the job market, industry conditions, and the realistic availability of comparable positions. Where the market for your skills is limited, specialized, or currently contracted, courts may award a longer notice period to reflect that reality.
ESA minimum vs. common law reasonable notice
ESA minimum notice
- 1 week per completed year of service
- Maximum 8 weeks regardless of length of service
- Fixed by statute with no flexibility
- Most severance offers are based on this number only
Common law reasonable notice
- Calculated using the Bardal factors on your specific circumstances
- No fixed maximum, reaching 24 months or more for long-serving senior employees
- Typically significantly higher than the ESA minimum
- Applies unless your contract contains a valid termination clause limiting it
Were you offered a severance package that only reflects the ESA minimum?
The ESA caps notice at 8 weeks regardless of how long you worked. Common law has no cap. For many employees, the difference is months of additional compensation. Get your package reviewed before you accept it.
Find Out What You Are Owed Or call us: 1-800-771-7882Signs your severance offer may be too low
Mitigation: what you are expected to do after termination
After a without-cause termination, you have a legal obligation to take reasonable steps to find new comparable employment. This is called mitigation. If you do not make reasonable efforts to mitigate your losses, a court may reduce your reasonable notice award to reflect the income you could have earned. Mitigation does not mean accepting any job offered. It means making genuine, documented efforts to find comparable work. Keep records of all your job search activity including applications, interviews, and outcomes.
Frequently asked questions about the Bardal factors and severance in BC
What are the Bardal factors in BC?
The Bardal factors are the principles BC courts use to calculate common law reasonable notice when an employee is dismissed without cause. They come from Bardal v. Globe and Mail Ltd. (1960) and cover the character of employment, length of service, age of the employee, and the availability of similar employment. These factors are weighed together on a case-by-case basis to determine what is fair rather than applying a fixed formula.
How much severance am I owed in BC?
At minimum you are owed the ESA notice entitlement of one week per completed year of service up to eight weeks. Beyond that, common law reasonable notice calculated using the Bardal factors may entitle you to significantly more. For a senior employee in their fifties with ten or more years of service, common law notice commonly reaches twelve to eighteen months or more. The only way to know what your specific situation is worth is to have it assessed by a lawyer.
Can my employer limit my severance to the ESA minimum?
Only if your employment contract contains a valid, enforceable termination clause that limits your entitlement to the ESA minimum. Many such clauses are unenforceable under current BC law because of how they are drafted or because they fail to meet ESA requirements. If your contract contains a termination clause, get it reviewed by a lawyer before accepting any offer based on it.
What is mitigation and does it affect my severance?
Mitigation is the legal obligation to take reasonable steps to find comparable new employment after termination. If you do not make reasonable efforts to mitigate, a court may reduce your notice award to reflect income you could have earned. You are not required to accept any job. Only to make genuine efforts to find comparable work. Document all job search activity including applications, interview outcomes, and any offers received or declined.
Should I sign my severance offer quickly?
No. Once you sign a release you waive your right to pursue additional compensation. Most severance offers are based only on the ESA minimum and do not reflect your common law entitlement. Employers sometimes set short deadlines to create pressure to sign before you can get advice. There is almost always time to have your package reviewed. Get legal advice before signing anything.
Is the common law reasonable notice calculation different in BC and Ontario?
The Bardal factors and the underlying framework for calculating reasonable notice are the same in BC and Ontario. Both provinces apply the same four factors and the same contextual analysis. The ESA minimums differ slightly between the two provinces but the common law framework operates identically. Cases from either province are regularly cited in courts across Canada.
Were you offered a severance package in BC? Get it reviewed before you sign.
Most severance packages reflect only the ESA minimum. Common law reasonable notice, calculated using the Bardal factors on your specific circumstances, is frequently significantly higher. Our team advises employees across BC on termination without cause and severance entitlements. Contact us for a confidential consultation.
Call us at 1-800-771-7882 or fill out the form below and we will be in touch.
The article in this client update provides general information and should not be relied on as legal advice or opinion. This publication is copyrighted by Achkar Law Professional Corporation and may not be photocopied or reproduced in any form, in whole or in part, without the express permission of Achkar Law Professional Corporation. ©