Performance Reviews: Legal Best Practices

Performance reviews are essential tools for evaluating employee productivity, aligning individual goals with business objectives, and improving workplace performance. In Ontario, however, these reviews must be carried out with legal care and consistency to avoid potential liability. Employers must ensure their evaluation practices comply with Ontario’s employment and human rights laws.

This article outlines the legal best practices for performance reviews in Ontario, the potential legal pitfalls employers should avoid, and how an employment lawyer can assist in implementing effective and compliant evaluation strategies.

Understanding the Legal Framework for Performance Evaluations

In Ontario, several legal statutes govern the employment relationship, including performance assessments. The Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) sets out minimum employment standards, including termination and notice requirements. The Ontario Human Rights Code prohibits discriminatory practices in employment decisions, including performance reviews. The Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) imposes obligations related to mental and physical well-being in the workplace.

Employers must ensure their review processes are applied consistently and objectively, particularly when the results of those reviews could impact promotions, terminations, or disciplinary actions. Failure to conduct performance reviews fairly can expose employers to claims of discrimination, constructive dismissal, or wrongful termination.

Establishing a Fair and Legally Compliant Review Process

Develop Clear and Objective Criteria

To minimize risk, employers should develop standardized and role-specific performance criteria. The evaluation criteria must relate to the employee’s actual job duties and be free of subjectivity. This minimizes potential bias and ensures evaluations are based on performance rather than personal characteristics.

Deliver Specific and Constructive Feedback

Employers should provide measurable feedback that acknowledges both accomplishments and areas for improvement. Constructive performance reviews help employees develop and demonstrate that the employer is acting in good faith, particularly relevant when performance issues may lead to future termination or disciplinary action.

Document All Evaluations

Thorough documentation is a critical part of a defensible performance review process. Employers should keep detailed notes of evaluation meetings, the feedback given, and the employee’s responses. These records may become essential in defending decisions related to promotions, demotions, or dismissals in the event of a legal claim.

Addressing Underperformance and Disciplinary Actions

When performance issues persist, employers must respond with clear and progressive disciplinary measures. This includes setting timelines for improvement, offering support where appropriate, and documenting every step. Terminating an employee for poor performance without prior feedback or support may be considered unjust or even discriminatory under the Ontario Human Rights Code.

Employers should also be aware of their duty to accommodate. If an employee’s performance is affected by a protected ground, such as disability or family status, the employer must explore accommodations before considering discipline or dismissal. Failing to do so could result in a human rights complaint or legal liability.

Human Rights Considerations in Performance Reviews

Performance reviews must be free from discriminatory assumptions or biases. For example, penalizing an employee for taking a parental leave or for medical-related absences could violate the Ontario Human Rights Code. Employers should ensure managers are trained to recognize and eliminate unconscious bias during the review process.

Employers must also accommodate employees where required by law. This may involve adjusting job expectations or timelines based on individual circumstances. Incorporating accommodation considerations into the performance review process is both a legal obligation and a best practice.

How Achkar Law Can Help Employers

Conducting performance reviews without legal guidance can lead to significant risks for employers, including wrongful dismissal claims, discrimination allegations, or complaints to the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario (HRTO).

Achkar Law assists employers across Ontario in implementing performance management strategies that align with employment legislation and human rights obligations. Our team of employment lawyers offers:

Review and development of legally compliant performance evaluation frameworks
Guidance on handling underperformance while minimizing legal exposure
Advice on accommodation obligations and human rights considerations
Support during workplace conflicts or disputes arising from poor reviews
Legal representation in case of claims related to termination or discrimination

Employers dealing with complex review scenarios, particularly where discipline or termination may result, benefit from legal advice early in the process. If your business needs assistance with workplace investigations in Ontario matters or performance-related employment decisions, Achkar Law can provide the guidance and representation you require.

Conclusion

Performance reviews, when conducted properly, can support employee development and organizational growth. However, employers in Ontario must be mindful of their legal obligations when evaluating staff. A review process that is fair, transparent, and compliant with employment laws reduces legal risk and fosters a more effective workforce.

Employers should seek legal guidance when establishing performance management policies, especially when dealing with underperformance, accommodation issues, or potential terminations.

Contact Achkar Law

If your organization requires legal advice regarding performance evaluations or workplace policies, contact Achkar Law today. Our firm advises employers on employment standards compliance, accommodation issues, and performance management strategies across Ontario.

Reach out now at 1-800-771-7882 or email [email protected] to schedule a consultation with an experienced employment lawyer.

haleema sheraz

So glad I came here! I got the clarity I needed to deal with the issues I was facing. The lawyers here are extremely professional and knowledgeable.

SBA Donnelly

Excellent consultation; detailed, thorough, and compassionate.

Kathleen Wylie

I found this amazing law firm online and have been happy with the service from the start. Charles Millar was extremely knowledgeable and extraordinarily generous with his time. His compassion and passion were evident and I appreciated his thoroughness. I cannot recommend this firm more highly.

Paul Kenyon (Pepkeny)

I found this employment law firm among many others on the web. This one and Abby Richardson in particular was particularly emphatic, exceedingly prompt, polite and highly professional. I would highly recommend them for any legal ‘employment matter.

Hope Kurtesi

I had a wonderful experience speaking with the team at Achkar Law. They were thorough, kind and patient with all my questions. I highly recommend them.

Tara Jenks

I highly recommend this Law Firm

Sara Roberts

Great experience would recommend them!

My experience with Achklaw was amazing!
They listened to me throughly and answered
all my questions with a high degree of effectiveness
and immense care. Consequently, the time I spent there was extremely helpful and valuable.

Susan M.

I recently had a consultation with Charles about a tricky accommodation situation with my employer. He gave clear, honest, and practical advice that helped me understand both the legal side and the bigger picture. I really appreciated his knowledge of employment and human rights law, his straightforward talk about possible outcomes, and the fact that he respected my goals. He didn’t push expensive legal action — instead, he focused on giving me the information I needed to make the right decisions. Highly recommend if you’re looking for strong, real-world legal advice. (Tip: check out his webinars too — they’re really helpful!)

J Mitchell

Extremely impressed with the team at Achkar Law! It was a pleasure dealing with Chris and his outstanding team. The entire team was prompt when responding to my enquiries and were very easy to work with.

I encourage anyone looking for an employment lawyer to contact Achkar Law, they will not be disappointed!

Kevin Richardson

Recently, I contacted Achkar Law about a legal matter involving our company and I booked a one hour consultation to discuss our case in detail. I had a Zoom call with Filip, (it is so much easier than fighting traffic and meeting in a physical office) who is one of the Partners of the firm and he was able to give me some really excellent advice. All the issues and procedures, as well as expected costs, were clearly outlined by Filip, who has a calm disposition as opposed to myself, whom I am told can get excited while debating. This is why it is always advisable to retain professional legal representation as litigants tend to get emotional if they represent themselves.

I feel that our position on the matter was well understood by Filip at Achkar Law as he had read over our file before the Zoom meeting and had a good grasp of the issues involved. Legal matters are always quite stressful but we were put at ease when we discussed our case with him. After our meeting we decided to retain their services, and I was then able to relax knowing that we had the legal professionals of Achkar Law on our side protecting our legal interests.

I therefore recommend Achkar Law without hesitation.

A A

Spoke with Charles on an employment law matter and the whole process from contacting the firm to the session itself was seemless and professional. Charles is knowledgeable and was quite helpful. I would definitely recommend Achlar Law for friends and Family.

David Gorman

Excellent transaction. Spoke to Madison, she was empathetic, knowledgeable, very thorough and detailed. I highly recommend this Law Firm. Very happy with my choice.

Mack J.

Chris and the team was professional, supportive, and truly cared about my case. Highly recommend their expertise in employment law. 5 stars

Nicolas Rodriguez

It was a very pleasant experience dealing with Achkar Law lawyers. They were able to review my case and provide me with my legal rights and important information. What I liked the most was the quick response and professionalism.