Understanding Non-Disparagement Clauses
When employees and employers part ways, whether through termination, resignation, or settlement, it’s common for agreements to include a non-disparagement clause. This legal provision can significantly impact an individual’s ability to discuss their former employer and colleagues. But what does this clause actually mean, and what should employees be aware of before agreeing to it?
This article explores the ins and outs of non-disparagement clauses, including their meaning, limitations, and what employees give up when they agree to these terms.
What is a Non-Disparagement Clause?
A non-disparagement clause is a contractual agreement that prevents an individual from making any negative statements about their former employer or its employees. Essentially, it aims to protect the reputation of the employer and prevent the individual from publicly criticizing them, even if the criticisms are fact-based. These clauses are often included in severance packages, settlement agreements, or other employment-related legal documents.
While the wording of a non-disparagement clause can vary, the general purpose remains the same: to avoid any statements or actions that could harm the reputation or business interests of the employer.
The Scope of Non-Disparagement Clauses
Non-disparagement clauses can extend beyond direct criticism of an employer. Some clauses may also cover indirect actions, such as encouraging others to make negative comments on your behalf. This can include conversations with friends, colleagues, or even posts on social media. It’s important to understand that what you say in informal settings could still be interpreted as a breach of the agreement.
In some cases, individuals have unintentionally violated their non-disparagement agreements by making seemingly innocuous remarks that were later interpreted as harmful to the employer’s reputation. For example, private conversations about a past employer or venting on social media can lead to consequences if those statements are deemed disparaging.
Key Limitations of Non-Disparagement Clauses
While non-disparagement clauses might seem restrictive, they do come with certain limitations. For instance, the clause typically does not apply to statements made before the agreement was signed. This means that any negative comments you made about your employer before the agreement won’t be subject to the restrictions of the clause.
Additionally, factual statements that do not inherently carry a negative connotation are usually not considered disparagement. For example, stating that a lawsuit was settled or that employment ended without making any negative inferences about the company or its employees is typically not viewed as a breach.
However, each case is unique, and decision-makers will look at the context of statements to determine whether they amount to disparagement. It’s important to carefully review the language of the non-disparagement clause to fully understand what it covers.
Consequences of Violating a Non-Disparagement Clause
Once an employee agrees to a non-disparagement clause, it is critical to abide by its terms. Breaching the clause can lead to serious consequences, including the requirement to return any compensation received as part of the settlement or severance agreement.
For example, if the agreement specified that the employee would receive a severance package in exchange for not making disparaging comments, a breach of the clause could result in the employer demanding repayment of the severance amount. In some cases, the employer might pursue additional damages if the breach caused significant reputational harm.
Where no specific penalty is outlined, a decision-maker may still award general damages based on the harm caused to the employer. Even if the actual harm is minimal, employees can still be ordered to pay damages for violating the agreement itself.
Can Non-Disparagement Clauses Be Negotiated?
Non-disparagement clauses are not always set in stone. In some cases, employees may have the opportunity to negotiate the terms of the agreement before signing. It’s often a good idea to consult with a lawyer before agreeing to a non-disparagement clause, especially if you’re concerned about how it may impact your ability to speak about your experiences.
A lawyer can help negotiate language that is more favourable to the employee, such as limiting the clause to specific types of statements or actions. They can also ensure that the clause is reasonable and doesn’t unduly restrict the employee’s ability to discuss their work history or professional experiences.
When to Seek Legal Advice
Employees should always consider seeking legal advice before agreeing to any non-disparagement clause. Employment lawyers can provide valuable insights into whether the clause is fair, as well as how it may impact the employee’s future.
If you believe that a clause may be overly restrictive or that it could be a problem in the future, discussing it with a lawyer may help prevent any misunderstandings or unintentional breaches down the line. In some cases, legal counsel may be able to modify the terms or advise on ways to avoid violating the agreement.
Conclusion
Agreeing to a non-disparagement clause is not a decision to be taken lightly. While these clauses are common in settlement agreements, they carry significant implications for what employees can say about their former employer or colleagues in the future. Understanding the scope, limitations, and potential consequences of a breach is crucial before signing any such agreement.
For employees concerned about the impact of a non-disparagement clause, it is wise to consult with an employment lawyer. They can help ensure the agreement is reasonable and provide guidance on how to protect yourself from violating its terms.
Non-disparagement clauses are just one aspect of the complex landscape of employment law, and getting the right advice is key to protecting your rights and interests.
Need Guidance on a Non-Disparagement Clause?
If you’re being asked to sign a non-disparagement clause or believe you may have violated one, it’s essential to understand your rights and obligations. At Achkar Law, our experienced employment lawyers can help you address these complex clauses and ensure your interests are protected.
Get assistance today – Contact Achkar Law to discuss your situation and learn how we can help.
Contact us here or call us at 1 (800) 771-7882 for a confidential consultation.
Need Help Reviewing Your Termination Agreement?
Related
Restrictive Covenants in Employment Contracts
